Provin’ and Defendin’

January 28, 2011 at 8:06 AM 6 comments

It’s a scene that I won’t forget: Kim, one of my high school friends, was involved in a heated argument with her older sister Karen. They were going back-and-forth about an incident that occurred between Kim and a girl named Natalie, who was Karen’s best friend. Kim was vehemently denying Natalie’s version of the story and incensed that her sister was taking Natalie’s side rather than hers. I even tried to help Kim out by vouching for her statements. After listening to all the protests that went back and forth like a volley of tennis balls, Miss Mae Jessie (Kim and Karen’s 82-year old Grandmother) looked at Kim with vexation and finally spoke up.

“Awwww, SHADDUP, Gal!” she said irritably, making a shushing motion with her hand. We all jumped and instantly became silent.

Quit all that provin’ and defendin.’ Ain’t no use in you tryn’ ta convince that gal. She don’t believe you no way.”

Needless to say, at that point the argument was moot.

Not too long ago I had occasion to think about Miss Mae Jessie’s statement about “provin’ and defendin.’” I became embroiled in a Facebook “discussion” that started out weighing the merits of an article that appeared on entitled “Sex and the Single Black Woman” ( I won’t go into all the points of the article (after all, Reading is Fundamental – if you care to you can read it for yourself. And yes, I love you, too).

Someone commented that swirling was an option, and (channeling my high school days of piping in and supporting) I made a comment about what statistics show about the rate that Black men inter marry, how they don’t seem to worry about making that choice, and how Black women are reluctant because when they intermarry they are accused of abandoning the race, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.  (Want stats? feel free to read a very long report here There are tons more reports I could provide links to; but hey!  I’ll do us all a favor and shout “E.L.M.O.!”).

[Sidebar: Um, for those of you who didn’t read last week’s blog, E.L.M.O. means:





You see, I tend to over-explain sometimes – hence this sidebar and hence the title of this post. If you continue to read this blog you will probably discover that I’ll have to call on E.L.M.O. at least once during most of the posts. Don’t say I didn’t warn you.]

Suffice it to say that the temperature of the discussion very quickly moved to the boiling point (for me) when one of the guys made the comment, “Remember Massa,” and then (in my estimation) tried to dominate the conversation and do exactly what I’d stated in the first place – make Black women feel guilty for choosing to go into interracial relationships.

We wound up going back and forth about Massa; why we should remember him (or not); be aware of our history and yet move on (or not), Ad infinitum, Ad nauseum.

And suddenly, in the midst of the bickering back and forth, the “provin’ and defendin’” on both sides, came the voice of reason. A very wise Sistah on the boards known for her no-nonsense, shoot-from-the-hip ability to get to the heart of the matter and tell it like it T – I is, made a couple of comments that made me wonder if she was somehow related to ole Miss Mae Jessie. Sistah-Girl stated that Sistahs need to make like the Brothers and just do it. In essence, she thought it was foolish to waste a lot of time (and keystrokes) trying to justify or explain who we loved, or why – just love your man and keep it moving.

In other words, “Quit all that provin’ and defendin.’ Ain’t no use in you trynna convince [them]. [They] don’t believe you no way.”

I had an epiphany, I tell you.

Guess what? Everybody doesn’t need “enlightening,” or an “explanation.” Not only do they not need it, they don’t want it – and sometimes, truth be told, they didn’t ask for it. Explain for what? Sure, there will be some who will have questions and genuinely want to know more – and the people in this category are grown enough to inquire. Those who want to live in the past, denigrate an entire race of people for things that happened before any of us were born, or choose to let the long, hurtful arm of the past reach over and taint their present and their future, will continue to do so. Others who elect to build on the foundation of the past, infused with – and inspired by – the resilience, strength and grace of their ancestors, and move forward embracing the joys of today and the promise of the future, will continue to do so. There’s no need for either side to engage in provin’ and defendin’.  At worst, we can shut each other down and shut each other out, and not believe each other no way. At best, we can live in peace and harmony, agree to disagree – and keep it moving.

Entry filed under: Uncategorized. Tags: , , , , , , , , , , .

The Things You People Do Party of Five

6 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Michelle  |  January 28, 2011 at 10:40 AM


  • 2. A Swirl Girl  |  January 28, 2011 at 8:02 PM

    Michelle, thanks!

  • 3. Kee  |  February 4, 2011 at 8:58 PM

    Well said!!! At times, defending your stance is nothing but a waste of words, especially when those words fall on deaf ears and a heart of stone.

  • 4. A Swirl Girl  |  February 4, 2011 at 10:34 PM

    Kee – I could not have said it better myself. That is a lesson WELL LEARNED. As tempted as some people’s stupidity may make me, I’ve that since ignorance must be bliss (for them) I’m going to keep it moving and let him/her remain deliriously happy!

  • 5. Barbara Francois  |  February 10, 2011 at 4:34 PM

    Girl…This was right on point. In fact one of my friends just last night on the phone told me the same thing that Miss Mae Jessie (was that her name?)…stop trying to prove and defend. You don’t owe anyone an explanation. Very wise advise…and saves a lot of energy. I myself will be implementing that little piece of advice.

  • 6. A Swirl Girl  |  February 11, 2011 at 4:09 PM


    I’ve implemented it also and it’s amazing how “freeing” it has become. Most people’s minds are already made up – I won’t convince them and they won’t convince ME. Far better to skip the aggravation and stress and just move on to someone who genuinely has an open mind!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 109 other followers

What I’m doing now:

Participating in NaBloPoMo!

Twitter Followers

Twitter Counter for @ASwirlGirl

Twitter Updates

January 2011

Blogs I Follow

Sometimes I Write

Yea sometimes I like to write, what do you do?

Jay Colby

Life, Inspiration & Motivation

Brown Girl Reading

Reading in color one page at a time...

Nerdy Thirty-Something

A geek who's married to a geek & geeks out on more than she should.

Tia Delano

Financial Analyst and Consultant

Wonderhys Studios

An otaku revolution like never before~

Wine'ing Momma

More Wine...Less Whine!

the one who writes

Honey sweet romances with a sexy sting. Y’all better have some!

The Swirl World

Celebrating and Elevating Black Women - mind, body, soul and spirit!


You'll be joining us soon!

Jambo Robyn

Stories about ordinary things

African-American Culture 101

A Safe Place for White People To Learn About Black People

Chocolate Chick in China

The Adventures of an English Teacher in China

Alisa presents

Quips + Pics + Recipes + Books + Beauty


At the intersections of Blackness, culture, and adulting.

Beatnik Radio

All things business, all things beat.

Trisha Rushing

The Journey of Life


"Life begins at the end of your comfort zone."

Free comedy podcast about a straigh-up interracial couple who talks about their personal issues and anything else we see, read or read from a black or white perspective. Follow us @chonilladotcom!

Nail Your Novel

Nail Your Novel - Writing, publishing and self-publishing advice from a bestselling ghostwriter and book doctor


Promoting The Beauty Of Natural Hair Care

The Adventures of SwirlMan

One White Guy's Attempts At Dating Black Women

To Be Aware

It's all about disbelieving your thoughts

Positive Mind Of Mine

My words for your eyes. :) Positive ideas for all!

Creative Juicer

Made fresh, served weekly.

Cee, What happened was

Something to write home about


tell a redemptive story with your life. now.

Reclaim your right to be loved, valued, supported and protected.♥

What Women Never Hear

Relationship management made easier


Unfathomable, Erratic, Nutty . . . ItsHerWords

%d bloggers like this: